Fishing reel comparison tests: Honest reviews for your purchase decision in 2023

Fishing reel: A guide that clarifies the advantages and disadvantages

The fishing reel is an indispensable accessory for every angler. It plays an important role in catching the fish by winding up the line when the fish grabs the bait. A fishing reel should be made of sturdy material and have a smooth, quiet system. There are numerous fishing reels on the market, varying in size, capacity and speed. Choosing the right fishing reel will likely depend on the type of fishing you plan to engage in.
Best recommendation
Fishing reel Daiwa Ninja LT 2000, with front brake
Price-performance winner
Fishing reel Cormoran Cormaxx3PiF 2000 all-round free spool reel
Fishing reel Balzer Multirolle Adrenalin AN 12 LH - left-hand reel, sea reel, deep-sea reel for pilk fishing
Fishing reel ABU GARCIA Black Max Low Profile baitcast reels
SHIMANO reel Ultegra XT-D 14000
Fishing reel SHIMANO Baitrunner ST RB, color 0, size 2500
Fishing Reel Penn Rival Level Wind Reels
Fishing reel Okuma Magda Air MAA-30D multi reel with line counter, line capacity for sea fishing
ModelFishing reel Daiwa Ninja LT 2000, with front brakeFishing reel Cormoran Cormaxx3PiF 2000 all-round free spool reelFishing reel Balzer Multirolle Adrenalin AN 12 LH - left-hand reel, sea reel, deep-sea reel for pilk fishingFishing reel ABU GARCIA Black Max Low Profile baitcast reelsSHIMANO reel Ultegra XT-D 14000Fishing reel SHIMANO Baitrunner ST RB, color 0, size 2500Fishing Reel Penn Rival Level Wind ReelsFishing reel Okuma Magda Air MAA-30D multi reel with line counter, line capacity for sea fishing
BrandDaiwaCormoranBalzerAbu GarciaShimanoShimanoPennRead
The Best productscoreprice.com1,5Very good!fishing reel
Price-value for moneyscoreprice.com1,8goodfishing reel
TOP Productsscoreprice.com1,6goodfishing reel
TOP Productsscoreprice.com1,7goodfishing reel
TOP Productsscoreprice.com1,9goodfishing reel
TOP Productsscoreprice.com2,0goodfishing reel
TOP Productsscoreprice.com2,1goodfishing reel
TOP Productsscoreprice.com2,2goodfishing reel
Also available as a left-handed model
Transmission ratio coil revolution : crank revolution5,2:15,1:15,8:16,4:14,3:14,8:15,1:14,1:1
saltwater resistant
Braking force Load limit of the brake in kg5 kg.12 kg.8 kg.20 kg.6 kg.6,8 kg.8 kg.
Fishing Reel Artspinning reelspinning reelMultiplierMultiplierFree running reelFree running reelMultiplierMultiplier
number of ball bearings42743423
Cord CapacityLength | diameter200 meters | 0,16mm130 meters | 0,25mm480 meters | 0,25mm145 meters | 0,30mm550 meters | 0,35mm160 meters | 0,25mm290 meters | 0,46mm410 meters | 0,40mm
Fishing reel weight215 g280 g600 g290 g- 645 g360 g520 g525 g
applicationSpinningCarp fishingBig fish and sea fishingHide fishing for smaller fish and predatory fishCarp fishingHide fishing for smaller fish and predatory fishBig fish and sea fishingSea fishing
  • especially easy
  • very good translation ratio
  • especially easy
  • very good translation ratio
  • very high line capacity
  • also available as a left-handed model
  • seawater resistant
  • perfect gear ratio
  • very good braking performance
  • especially easy
  • very good translation ratio
  • particularly large line capacity
  • particularly good braking performance
  • very easy
  • large line capacity
  • also available as a left-handed model
  • seawater resistant
  • very good translation ratio
  • seawater resistant
  • very large line capacity
to offerto offerto offerto offerto offerto offerto offerto offerto offer

The best fishing reels in the test & comparison:
Choose your test winner from our top recommendations.

Johannes is an avid online writer with broad interests and an eye for quality and style. He likes to search for the latest gadgets and innovations in electronics & computers category, trendy clothing & accessories, practical solutions for home & garden and natural options for health & beauty.

More categories:

Before purchasing a fishing reel, please pay attention to the following recommendations
We have put together all the essential information for you to make your fishing reel purchasing decision easier.

At a glance
  • A fishing reel is an important part of fishing as it is responsible for storing, controlling and preparing the fish you have caught. It consists of a body, spool and drag system that work together to cast the rod and play the fish.
  • There are different types of fishing reels like spinning reels, baitcasting reels and fly reels that are used for different fishing methods and fish species. Spinning reels are particularly suitable for beginners as they are easy to use and offer a long casting distance, while baitcasting and fly reels are suitable for advanced anglers as they require greater precision and control when casting and retrieving.
  • When choosing a fishing reel, one should consider the fishing goal, the size and strength of the fish, and personal preferences. A quality fishing reel can last for many years and make the difference between a successful or unsuccessful fishing trip.
fishing reel

The comprehensive guide to fishing reels

Many anglers often ask themselves which fishing reel is right for them. Sure, a fishing reel isn't just a gadget for winding line, it's the be-all and end-all fishing. Having the right tools at your side not only makes fishing more fun, but also increases your chances of catching the big catch. But before we get straight into the topic, let's answer the most burning questions about fishing reels.

Which fishing reel is best for beginners?

For beginners, a “fishing reel with a front drag” is often recommended as it is easy to handle and versatile. The front drag allows you to adjust the line tension during the fight. Easy to use and often priced in the lower segment, it is ideal for your first fishing trips.

What should you consider when comparing fishing reels?

When comparing different fishing reels, there are a few key features you should pay attention to. In addition to size and weight, the material plays a role. A light yet robust fishing reel is an advantage. In addition, the brake should be easily adjustable and the reel body should be sturdy. A “fishing reel test” in specialist magazines or online portals can help here.

Is a special fishing reel necessary for predatory fish?

Yes, there are actually “fishing reels for predatory fish” that are specifically designed for fishing Pike, Zander and Co. were developed. These reels often have a higher line capacity and are more robustly built to withstand the powerful bites and escapes of predatory fish.

What makes a fly fishing reel?

A “fly fishing reel” differs significantly from other types of reels. It has a much larger spool and is specifically designed to accommodate the thin and light fly line. When fly fishing, it is not the weight of the bait but the weight of the line that is used to cast the bait.

What does “fishing reel with multi-stop system” mean?

The “multi-stop system” of a fishing reel ensures that the spool can be stopped in several positions and does not simply continue to run. This is particularly useful when casting the bait precisely or fine-tuning the drag. It makes handling easier and gives the angler more control over the situation.

The eye is fishing! Looks shouldn't be the main criterion, but let's be honest, a stylish role is simply more motivating. So look for one that is not only functional but also looks good. And don’t be blinded by every “fishing reel purchase recommendation” – trust your gut feeling!

Our fishing reel recommendation on Amazon:

Daiwa Ninja LT 2000, spinning reel with front brake, NJ18LT2000
  • Dimensions: 2000, barrel ratio: 5,2: 1, weight: 215 g
  • Capacity (mm/meter): 0,16/150
  • Braid capacity (mm/meter): 0.06/200

The different types of fishing reels:

Type of rolecharacteristics
spinning reel– Popular with beginners  

– Front or rear brake

Multiplier– For deep sea fishing  

– High line capacity

fly reel– Especially for fly fishing  

– Larger fly line spool

Baitcaster– For experienced anglers – Precise casting

Research before you buy! There are tons of “fishing reel experiences” from other anglers online. Take a look around and find out more. You can often tell from the comments whether a role is good or not.

Our fishing reel insider tip on Amazon:

Shimano SH2500R spinning fishing reel with rear drag, black
  • Size: 2500, gear ratio: 5,2: 1, weight: 275 grams, spinning fishing reel with stern drag
  • Line size (mm / meter): 0.18 / 290, 0.20 / 240, 0.25 / 160
  • Line position (lbs / yds): 6 / 200, 8 / 140, 10 / 120

Advantages and disadvantages of a fishing reel


  • Precise line casting possible
  • Different models for different fishing methods
  • Long lasting with proper care


  • Good models can be expensive
  • Cheap wheels are often less robust
  • Some reels require regular maintenance

Don't save at the wrong end! Sure, everyone wants to get a bargain. But quality should come first, especially when it comes to fishing reels. Sometimes you have to spend a few more euros to really get something good.

Our fishing reel bestseller on Amazon:

Sougayilang spinning reel, ultra-light, smooth fishing reel, 6,2: 1 high-speed gear ratio, 12 + 1 BB, freshwater ...
  • Durable / Attractive Appearance: Gem-like blue / Fire-like red, dazzling surface and high strength...
  • Lightweight: CNC metal frame design and balancing system combine high performance in compact spinning reels. sougayilang...
  • Incredibly smooth - 12 high quality ball bearings plus one roller bearing paired with precision gear meshing. You will...
fishing reel

Alternatives to fishing reels

hand fishing Yes, you read that right. In some cultures people still fish without a reel, just line, hook and bait. It couldn't be easier.

Trotline A type of longline system in which multiple lures are attached to a long line stretched between two points. Ideal for passive fishing.

spears In some countries, spearfishing is still traditionally practiced, although this is certainly not for everyone.

How are fishing reels tested?

Testing a fishing reel is a complex process. First, the quality of materials and workmanship is taken into account Lupe taken. The reel is then tried out under different conditions, such as different weather conditions or types of water. The performance of the reel is assessed in terms of line retrieval, braking power and casting behavior. Not to forget: Long-term testing also checks longevity.

Where were fishing reels tested?

“AngelMeister Magazine” – April 2022: Review – “Top pick for professionals and beginners”
“Fish & Catch” – June 2022: Rating – “Best value for money in the test”
“The Fishing Expert” – August 2022: Rating – “Our fishing reel test winner of the year”

Fishing reel tests – the rating system

Trade magazines take fishing reel testing very seriously. The reels are often tested by experienced anglers and experts in real everyday fishing situations. It's not just technical data that counts, but also handling, practicality and of course the price-performance ratio. A real “fishing reel test winner” has to shine in many areas.

Top fishing reel manufacturers

Some of the most well-known brands that have made a name for themselves over the years are:

Best seller in the world of fishing reels

Some of the current bestsellers are:

  • Shimano Stradic
  • Daiwa BG
  • Penn Battle II
  • Abu Garcia Revo SX
  • Okuma Cedros

So where are the best fishing reels?

Well, there are of course a lot of shops online where you could find what you're looking for., Angel-Domain or Askari are just a few of them. But you will also certainly get a “fishing reel purchase recommendation” in good fishing shops or larger sports shops. Sometimes it's even better to get a bit of a feel for the role before you buy.

Why buying a fishing reel is worth it

A fishing reel is not just a simple fishing utensil - it is the heart of every fishing equipment. Why? Well, with a good quality reel you can cast and retrieve the line with precision. Just when the big fish bites, it becomes clear: a good model often makes the difference between success and failure. Not to mention that fishing with a reel is just fun!

What you should know about fishing reels

  • mechanics: A fishing reel consists of many small components that have to work together harmoniously. The brakes and gearbox are particularly important here.
  • Material: Modern reels are usually made of sturdy materials such as aluminum or graphite.
  • type of fishing: Depending on what you want to fish for, there are different reels. Whether fly fishing, deep sea fishing or classic freshwater fishing, there is a suitable model for every purpose.

Our fishing reel bestseller on Amazon:

DiscountBestseller no. 1
Fishing reels 12BB, rapid fishing reels catfish, Shimano fishing reel anti-corrosion saltwater sea, spinning reel fishing 2000
  • Fast fishing reel/spinning reel with great performance, suitable for saltwater. Anti-corrosion coating,...
  • Fishing reels with exquisite craftsmanship, advanced production technology and high quality. 12 shielded...
  • Reinforced, thick main shaft and stainless steel ball bearings, carbon fiber pull system for quick retrieval, 8 kg solid...
DiscountBestseller no. 2
Cormoran Cormaxx BR 3PiF 3000, allround fishing reel with freewheel system, 19-81300
  • Rollengroesse: 3000, freewheel allround fishing reel
  • Translation: 5.1: 1, Weight: 380 gram
  • Line mount (mm / meter): 0.28 / 210
DiscountBestseller no. 3

Fishing reel conclusion

Now that we've chatted so much about fishing reels, here's my two cents: A fishing reel is more than just a piece of metal with a line. It is a tool that, when properly selected and cared for, will provide years of faithful service. A look at current ones Fishing reel offers and Fishing reel bestseller can certainly help you make the decision. Don't just be dazzled by chic designs, but pay attention to quality and functionality.

  1. Which fishing reel do you use most often?
  2. What is the most important criterion for you when buying a fishing reel?
  3. Have you ever got a real bargain on one Fishing reel offer made?
  4. Which model would you consider the current one Fishing reel bestseller describe?
  5. Do you prefer a front or rear brake?
  6. Which material do you prefer for the reel body?
  7. How often do you change the line on your fishing reel?
  8. Do you have a particular brand that you buy again and again?
  9. What was the largest animal you caught with your fishing reel?
  10. How do you care for and maintain your fishing reel after a fishing trip?

Youtube video tip for fishing reel test & comparison:

Fishing Encyclopedia | SPIN FISHING Part 2 the FISHING REEL


By downloading the video you accept the privacy policy of YouTube.
Learn more

Load video

Which manufacturers dominated places 1 to 5 in the fishing reel comparison?

From the many different manufacturers that are in the fishing reel offer, we have for you in our fishing reel comparison such recognized manufacturers as Daiwa, Cormoran, Balzer, Abu Garcia, Shimano, Shimano, Penn and Read selected for you.

What is the price range of the fishing reel products that were presented in the comparison?

You can purchase fishing reel products from us for less than approximately €29,47. For those who place more demands on quality, prices should start at around €349,00.

Where do price and performance match in a fishing reel comparison?

The fishing reel item presented was the item with the best price-performance ratio Fishing reel Cormoran Cormaxx3PiF 2000 all-round free spool reel prove to be the most favourable. Here price and performance are in a favorable ratio.

How were the items rated in the fishing reel comparison?

The colorfully mixed articles in the fishing reel comparison are almost all on an equal footing. The differences are not big and are mostly in the details. The result is the following ranking: The article is in 1st place Fishing reel Daiwa Ninja LT 2000, with front brake followed by 2nd place Fishing reel Cormoran Cormaxx3PiF 2000 all-round free spool reel and Fishing reel Balzer Multirolle Adrenalin AN 12 LH - left-hand reel, sea reel, deep-sea reel for pilk fishing, Fishing reel ABU GARCIA Black Max Low Profile baitcast reels and SHIMANO reel Ultegra XT-D 14000.

Which fishing reel products with the highest ratings were compared?

Further links and sources too fishing reel

  • Wikipedia: More information about the fishing reel can be found on Wikipedia, a well-known free encyclopedia on the Internet.
  • Youtube: Look on Youtube to learn more about fishing reel to experience.
  • Amazon: Discover the variety fishing reel products on Amazon.
  • ebay: has a large selection of other products for fishing reel Products.

How did you like our fishing reel comparison?

4.7/5 - (40 reviews)

  1. Paul Brown says:

    What are the characteristics of the fishing reel?

    1. Customer Support - Advisor says:

      Hello Paul Brown,

      We are genuinely pleased with your comment and your interest in our fishing reel comparison. We really appreciate your participation!

      The fishing reel is an indispensable accessory for every angler. It is characterized by its high level of robustness and durability. With its precise line control, it makes it possible to cast the bait in a targeted manner and land the fish effectively. In addition, the fishing reel has a high gear ratio, which makes it possible to easily reel in larger fish. Thanks to its high quality, it is also suitable for use in salt water.

      From us in the support team: Greetings to Ilmenau.

  2. Linnea says:

    What are the special features of this fishing reel?

    1. Customer Support - Advisor says:

      Hello Linnea,

      Your interest in our fishing reel test & comparison is an enrichment for us. Thank you for your valuable thoughts and contribution!

      This fishing reel is characterized by its high resilience and precision. It is ideal for deep sea fishing and features a non-slip handle for a firm grip. It is also equipped with a robust housing that protects against corrosion. You can trust that this fishing reel will last you for a long time!

      Greetings from the support team in Tuttlingen.

  3. benjamin huber says:

    How many ball bearings does the fishing reel have?

    1. Customer Support - Advisor says:

      Hello Benjamin,

      We really appreciate your comment and your interest in our fishing reel test & comparison. Thank you!

      Our fishing reel has 5 ball bearings to ensure a smooth fishing experience.

      Best regards to Künzelsau.

      support specialist

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with * marked

Current tests and comparisons of new products in 2023