Updated: 14.05.2024

Umbrella 2024: Independent tests and comparisons for the wisest choice

Recommended umbrella 2024: expert tips for your needs

Umbrella: The umbrella is an essential accessory on rainy days. Whether on the way to work or a walk in the park, it protects us from rain and wind. There are now many different variants and designs, from classic black to bright colors and unusual motifs. The size and materials also vary, from handy pocket umbrellas to large golf umbrellas. A good umbrella should be robust and stable to withstand strong winds. Our product tip: the automatic pocket umbrella with windproof function that fits perfectly in any handbag.
Best recommendation
Umbrella Adoric Stormproof up to 140 km/h pocket umbrella
Price-performance winner
Umbrella iX-brella XXL rainbow 129 cm fiberglass, light
Umbrella Royal Walk Large XXL 54 inch automatic, wooden handle
Umbrella VON HEESEN ® stormproof incl. umbrella bag
Umbrella Carlo Milano umbrella: set of 2 transparent, Ø 100 cm
Umbrella Knirps pocket umbrella A.200 Medium Duomatic
Model Umbrella Adoric Stormproof up to 140 km/h pocket umbrella Umbrella iX-brella XXL rainbow 129 cm fiberglass, light Umbrella Royal Walk Large XXL 54 inch automatic, wooden handle Umbrella VON HEESEN ® stormproof incl. umbrella bag Umbrella Carlo Milano umbrella: set of 2 transparent, Ø 100 cm Umbrella Knirps pocket umbrella A.200 Medium Duomatic
Brand Adoric Ix Brella Royal Walk From Heesen Carlo Milano Knirps
The Best Suggestionsscoreprice.com1,5Very good!Umbrella
Price-value for moneyscoreprice.com1,8goodUmbrella
TOP Productsscoreprice.com1,6goodUmbrella
TOP Productsscoreprice.com1,7goodUmbrella
TOP Productsscoreprice.com1,9goodUmbrella
TOP Productsscoreprice.com2,0goodUmbrella
additional colors Blue no further no further Blue no further Blue Violet Navy Red and more
Carrying comfort: Handling of grip and pole length big grip | could be a little thicker good grip length for up to average sized hands big grip | could be a little thicker big grip | could be a little thicker big grip | could be a little thicker big grip | could be a little thicker
umbrella guy Pocket umbrella retractable Stick umbrella large umbrella diameter Stick umbrella large umbrella diameter Pocket umbrella retractable Stick umbrella large umbrella diameter Pocket umbrella retractable
diameter of the screen Diameter: 105 cm Diameter: 129 cm Diameter: 120 cm Diameter: 95 cm Diameter: 100 cm Diameter: 97 cm
quality of workmanship very good workmanship extremely good workmanship extremely good workmanship very good workmanship very good workmanship very good workmanship
Storm and wind resistance very stable extremely stable extremely stable very stable very stable very stable
Open/close automatic
  • extremely stable
  • compact size
  • sturmfest
  • slightly shortened overall length
  • extremely stable
  • can accommodate 2 people
  • can accommodate 2 people
  • extremely stable
  • elegant design
  • very comfortable to wear
  • extremely stable
  • including umbrella bag and travel case
  • 2er Pack
  • transparent roof
  • heavy-duty steel frame
  • great color selection
  • compact size
  • sturmfest
to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer

The best umbrella in the test & comparison:
Choose your test winner from our top recommendations.

Hello everyone! My name is Lucas and it is a pleasure to be here as an author. As a hobby gardener, my focus is particularly on the “Household & Garden” category. Here I plan to write articles about gardening and garden maintenance. My enthusiasm for plants and gardening is reflected in my writing style. But my interests extend far beyond the garden. I have dealt intensively with “Furniture & Furnishings” and am always on the lookout for the latest trends for an appealing living atmosphere. Additionally, the Food & Beverage, Health & Wellness, and Beauty & Personal Care categories are areas that I am knowledgeable and passionate about. I attach great importance to quality and a healthy lifestyle. I also expect to publish articles in these fields in the future. My goal is to offer readers added value and I look forward to lively exchanges and feedback on my contributions.

More categories:

Umbrella Buying Recommendations in 2024: Ultimate Guide and Current Trends
This is how you make the right product choice based on the umbrella comparison mentioned above.

At a glance
  • An umbrella is a useful accessory that is mainly used when it is raining. It protects the user from moisture and moisture. There are different types of umbrellas such as collapsible, automatic or stick umbrellas.
  • Umbrellas can be made from different materials such as polyester, nylon or cotton. There are also special umbrellas with UV protection that protect against the sun's rays in summer. Umbrellas come in a variety of sizes and designs, from plain and solid to colorful and patterned.
  • Umbrellas are not only practical, but also a fashion accessory. There are many well-known brands that specialize in producing high-quality umbrellas. Some of the most popular brands include Knirps, Doppler or esprit. Umbrellas can be purchased online or in brick-and-mortar stores.

The umbrella – More than just rain protection

It's dripping from above, the sky is darkening - sometimes just a few raindrops are enough to make us wish for a solid umbrella. But what really makes a good umbrella? And what should you pay attention to when buying? This article answers the most burning questions about umbrellas and gives you a comprehensive insight.

What makes a good umbrella?

A good umbrella is characterized not only by its waterproofness, but also by its wind resistance. It's no use if the thing falls over at the first gust of wind, right? In addition, the mechanism, i.e. opening and closing, should work reliably. Some models also feature a UV protection coating, which can be particularly beneficial on sunny days.

What should you pay attention to when testing and comparing umbrellas?

By the umbrella Test and comparison should be done in addition to water resistance and wind stability also pay attention to the material and workmanship. Is the Non-slip handle? What material was used for the covering? A comparison different models can help you find the right umbrella for your needs.

Why choose special “umbrellas for weddings and events”?

Special ones are often made for special occasions such as weddings or events Umbrellas chosen. These are characterized by a more elegant design and go better with formal clothing. They are often white or in delicate pastel tones. Of course, functionality shouldn't be neglected - after all, nobody wants to get wet at their own wedding.

How effective is an “umbrella with UV protection coating”?

An “umbrella with UV protection coating” not only offers protection from rain, but also from the sun’s harmful UV rays. This can be particularly beneficial in the summer months or in regions with strong sunlight. These umbrellas protect the skin from sunburn and can help reduce the risk of skin diseases. So if you're often outside, you should think about purchasing such an umbrella.

 quality over quantity

Many people make the mistake of choosing cheap umbrellas. But here the rule is: quality over quantity! A higher quality Umbrella lasts longer, offers better protection and is a better investment in the long run.

Our umbrella recommendation on Amazon:

Royal Walk Large XXL 54 inch automatic travel golf umbrella for women and men Stormproof Windproof Lightweight Classic for 2 ...
  • ✔️ AMAZING STRONG WINDPROOF FRAME CONSTRUCTION - Do you need a golf umbrella that can stand the test of the toughest ...
  • ✔️ BIG ENOUGH FOR 2 PEOPLE - With its 39 inches (99cm) length and 47 inches (120cm) diameter, our Royal ...

Types of umbrellas and their features

Compaction characteristics
folding umbrella Compact, lightweight, fits in every pocket
umbrella Stable, robust, ideal for wind and weather
automatic umbrella Opens automatically at the push of a button
Golf umbrella Large, optimal protection, ideal for outdoor activities
children umbrella Smaller size, child-friendly designs

Always stay informed

It never hurts to do some research before purchasing. Check out the latest Umbrella test winner and get one Umbrella buy recommendation from experts. So you are always on the safe side.

Our umbrella insider tip on Amazon:

Adoric umbrella stormproof pocket umbrella umbrella umbrella quick-drying golf umbrella with drying bag Protects against rain and sun
  • AUTOMATIC FAST OPENING AND CLOSING: With the open and close button, you can open the umbrella in less than one ...
  • SUPER RESISTANT UMBRELLA AGAINST WIND: The flexible structure of the Adoric Umbrella made of high-quality fiberglass and stainless steel ...
  • STRONG MATERIALS: with a more durable 210T fabric that is more resilient than 190T fabric. The stainless steel structure...

Advantages and disadvantages of an umbrella:


  • Protection from rain and UV rays
  • Versatile designs for every taste
  • Different sizes and Shapes for different Occasions


  • Can fold over in strong winds
  • Cheap products often of inferior quality
  • Depending on the size, it is impractical to transport

The right size counts

A folding umbrella is super practical, but can... strong wind quickly reach its limits. So think carefully about the occasion and weather conditions for which you need the umbrella.

Our umbrella bestsellers on Amazon:

iX-brella umbrella XXL rainbow 129 cm fiberglass, light, colorful, large with soft handle
  • This umbrella with its 16 struts is something very special that will attract the attention of others
  • With twice as many spokes as normal, the umbrella has a nice, evenly round shape and a good...
  • With a diameter of almost 130 cm, the umbrella is big enough to keep you, your luggage and your partner dry even in heavy rain...

Alternatives to the umbrella:

  • rain poncho: Light, transportable and a real lifesaver, especially at festivals.
  • rain jacket and trousers: For everyone who likes sport and wants to go jogging despite the rain.
  • Rain hat or cap: Not for everyone, but sometimes really practical when you want to have your hands free.
  • Dancing in the rain: Yes, not a real alternative, but let's be honest, there's something there, right?

How umbrellas are tested:

Did you know that there are real umbrella tests? Here's a little insight into the process. Firstly, the waterproofing. Here we look at whether and how much water comes through the material. Secondly, the wind resistance. Many an umbrella folds over with the slightest breeze. And thirdly, the handling. An umbrella should be easy to open and close and fit comfortably in the hand.

Where are umbrellas tested?

Trade magazines such as “Weatherproof Companions” or “Schirm & Schild” regularly test the latest models. For example, “Schirm & Schild” has the in July 2022 Umbrella test winner chosen: The “SuperShield Pro” scored a rating of 1,3 (very good).

Test criteria from specialist magazines:

The criteria range from workmanship quality, value for money to environmental friendliness. The manufacturer's longevity and customer service often play a role in the reviews.

Stiftung Warentest and the umbrella: At the moment, Stiftung Warentest has not yet published a specific test on umbrellas. But of course that can always change.

The big players among the umbrella manufacturers:

The bestsellers among umbrellas:

The brands Knirps and Senz are particularly popular and are among the bestsellers. The “Knirps T.200 Medium Duomatic” or the “Senz° Automatic” can often be found in the top 10.

Where can I buy the best umbrellas?

Online shops like: Amazon, eBay or specialized sites like regen Schirm.de have a large selection. In retail you can find them at Karstadt, Galeria Kaufhof or in outdoor shops. And remember: a good one Umbrella buy recommendation can be worth its weight in gold before investing your money!

Why buy an umbrella?

  • No more wet surprises: Who hasn't it happened to? Suddenly the floodgates of heaven open and you find yourself right in the middle of it all.
  • A fashion statement: Yes, an umbrella can do more than just protect. In all shapes, colors and with the wildest designs it becomes real Eye-catcher.
  • Longevity: Anyone who has ever invested in a high-quality model knows that the thing lasts.

Interesting facts about the umbrella:

  • Material: Many umbrellas are made of polyester, but there are also some made of nylon or pongee.
  • Automatic vs. manual: An automatic umbrella opens at the push of a button, while manual ones require a bit of muscle strength.
  • UV protection: Not just against rain! Some umbrellas also offer protection from the sun's UV rays.

Our umbrella bestseller on Amazon:

DiscountBestseller no. 1
VON HEESEN® umbrella stormproof up to 140 km/h - incl. umbrella bag & travel case - pocket umbrella with automatic open-close function, small, light...
  • ✔ OPEN-CLOSE AUTOMATIC - Whether rain, wind or storm, the umbrella opens and closes with just one push of a button (95 ...
  • ✔ TEFLON COATING - Wind force 12 and wind speeds of up to 140 km/h are no problem, because the 210T ...
  • ✔ FRAME CONSTRUCTION - Large umbrellas are impractical for everyday use. Thanks to the stable frame construction and the...
Bestseller no. 2
Newaner umbrella stormproof, stick umbrella pocket umbrella with open-close automatic windproof portable, foldable weatherproof compact umbrella up to...
629 rating
Newaner umbrella stormproof, stick umbrella pocket umbrella with open-close automatic windproof portable, foldable weatherproof compact umbrella up to...
  • 【Automatic opening and closing】 This umbrella has an automatic opening and closing...
  • 【Small and Portable】The height of the umbrella is only 28,5cm. After folding it can be easily...
  • 【Sturdy and windproof】 With a steel frame umbrella frame, the steel frame is sturdy and the paint does not rust, 8 ...
DiscountBestseller no. 3
Knirps pocket umbrella A.200 Medium Duomatic - Compact and stormproof - Wind tunnel tested - Black
  • The compact umbrella can be easily opened and closed with the extra wide push button and automatic
  • It has a pleasantly large canopy and thus also offers space for 2 people
  • You can take the umbrella with you wherever you go, it is foldable and easy to transport with the carrying strap

Umbrella Conclusion

Umbrellas are not only practical everyday helpers, but in many cases real life savers. A good umbrella in your luggage gives you a feeling of security and won't let you down in the event of sudden rain. Although there are always cheap ones Umbrella offers, but quality should be the priority. A Umbrella bestseller often promises good value for money. So, invest in a good umbrella, it will thank you in the next rain shower.

We want to hear your opinion! Please enter your answers in the comment box below.

  1. Which brand is your absolute favorite umbrella?
  2. Have you ever bought an umbrella online?
  3. What color is your current favorite umbrella?
  4. You can also use your umbrella as a sunscreen?
  5. How often do you buy a new umbrella per year?
  6. Have you ever had one? Umbrella offer caught?
  7. Do you prefer an automatic or manual umbrella?
  8. What is most important to you in an umbrella: design, quality or price?
  9. Would you spend more money on a designer umbrella?
  10. Have you ever heard of one? Umbrella bestseller heard and if so, which one is it?

Youtube video recommendation for the umbrella test & comparison:

Folding umbrella test: tips for market purchase NDR


By downloading the video you accept the privacy policy of YouTube.
Read more

Load video

Comprehensive Guide to Umbrella: Top Sources for Information and Products

  • Discover more about Umbrella: Your Resource Guides

    • Umbrella Wikipedia: Get comprehensive information about Umbrella on Wikipedia, the renowned online encyclopedia that offers in-depth insight into a variety of topics.
    • Umbrella YouTube: Explore Umbrella through a variety of videos on YouTube. From informative tutorials to product reviews, YouTube offers a rich source of visual content.
    • Umbrella Amazon: Discover the extensive product range from Umbrella on Amazon. Here you will find a variety of options, user reviews and much more.
    • Umbrella eBay: Browse through a large selection Umbrella-Products on Ebay. This marketplace offers both new and used options that may meet your needs.

How did you like our umbrella comparison?

3.8/5 - (44 reviews)

Comments to "Umbrella" Comparison

  1. Florian Vogel says:

    Can the umbrella withstand strong wind?

    1. Customer Support - Advisor says:

      Hello Florian Vogel,

      Thank you very much for your valuable contribution and your participation in our umbrella comparison. We are grateful for your interest!

      Yes, this umbrella is specially designed to withstand strong winds. It has a robust frame and a sturdy umbrella fabric that provides reliable protection even in windy weather.

      With recommendations from the service desk for Heusenstamm.

  2. Bella says:

    Is the umbrella waterproof?

    1. Customer Support - Advisor says:

      Hello Bella,

      A big thank you for your feedback and your interest in our umbrella test & comparison. We appreciate it very much!

      Yes, the umbrella is waterproof and protects against rain and moisture.

      Greetings from the help department to customers in Dresden.

  3. Julian Arnold says:

    Is the umbrella water repellent?

    1. Customer Support - Advisor says:

      Hi Julian,

      We really appreciate your comment and your interest in our umbrella test & comparison. Thank you!

      Yes, our umbrella is coated with a water-repellent fabric to keep you dry when it rains.

      Best regards to Gardelegen.

      support specialist

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with * marked

Current tests and comparisons of new products in 2024